Differential Taxation for Reselling: VAT Only on the Margin
Vintage jackets from flea markets, sneakers from private collections, secondhand items in your own shop: If you resell items for commercial purposes and aren’t a small business owner, you owe VAT. The only question is, on what? On the total price or on the markup you add.
Under the margin taxation method pursuant to Section 25a of the UStG, commercial resellers pay VAT only on the margin—that is, the selling price minus the purchase price. Prerequisite: The goods were purchased without VAT, for example from private individuals. In 2025 and 2026, the tax rate will be 19%, calculated on the gross margin. There is no input tax on the purchase.
- The differential taxation applies to commercial resellers who have purchased movable property without paying VAT, typically from private individuals.
- Only the margin is taxed; the VAT is included in the margin and is deducted at a rate of 19/119.
- The standard tax rate of 19% always applies, even to goods that would otherwise be subject to a reduced tax rate.
- The invoice includes the note “Used goods/special rules”; a separate tax statement is not required.
- For the small business threshold, total revenue is what counts, not the profit margin.
What is the margin tax on reselling?
Differential taxation is a special rule under the VAT system: Instead of being levied on the entire sales price, the tax applies only to the difference between the sales price and the purchase price (Section 25a(3), first sentence, of the UStG). It applies to dealers who resell used goods on which no VAT was charged at the time of purchase.
The idea behind this is that if you buy a vintage jacket from a private individual, the purchase price does not include VAT that you can claim back as input tax. Without a special rule, you would have to pay 19% on the full sales price. The differential taxation therefore applies only to your profit margin.
Differential taxation – Special VAT rule for resellers (Section 25a of the UStG): Only the margin between the purchase price and the selling price is taxed, not the entire price. This applies only if the purchase was made without VAT, such as from private individuals.
This is how VAT is calculated under the differential taxation method
VAT is not included in the tax base (Section 25a(3), third sentence, of the UStG). Therefore, it is excluded from the margin: the margin divided by 1.19 yields a tax base of €84.03; 19% of that amount is €15.97.
Who is eligible to use the differential taxation method?
Resellers who have purchased movable property without paying VAT. The law specifies three requirements (Section 25a(1) of the UStG):
You are a reseller, which means you deal in tangible movable property on a commercial basis. The goods were delivered to you within the Community, i.e., within the EU, and no VAT was due on this delivery, or the supplier has already applied the differential tax rate. Precious stones and precious metals are excluded.
Typical for resellers: purchasing at flea markets, through classified ads, from household clear-outs, or directly from private collections. Purchases from small businesses also count (Section 25a.1, Paragraph 5 of the VAT Implementation Regulation). If, on the other hand, you buy new sneakers from a retailer with an invoice showing VAT, the requirement is not met. In that case, the standard tax rules apply to the resale, and you can deduct the VAT from the purchase invoice as input tax.
Where do the goods come from? What are the rules for resale?
| Shopping at | VAT on Purchases? | Resale |
|---|---|---|
| Private individual (flea market, classified ads, collection) | no | Differential taxation is possible |
| Retailer who sells under the differential tax system (note on the invoice) | not reported separately | Differential taxation is possible |
| Small business owner (invoice without VAT) | no | Differential taxation is possible |
| Retailer or brand with an invoice showing the VAT | yes | Standard taxation with input tax credit |
| Purchases Outside the EU (Imports) | Import Sales Tax | Standard Taxation; Special Provisions for Art and Collectibles in Section 25a(2) of the UStG |
Pursuant to Section 25a(1)(2) of the UStG and Section 25a.1(5) of the German Value-Added Tax Implementation Regulations (UStAE). Precious stones and precious metals are excluded. As of October 2026, tax years 2025 and 2026.
Are you a small business owner? Then that's not an issue
As a small business owner, you do not report VAT, and the differential taxation rule does not apply. Whether you qualify as a small business owner depends on your total revenue: no more than €25,000 in the previous year and no more than €100,000 in the current year (Section 19(1) of the UStG). For resellers, total revenue counts—not just the margin (Federal Fiscal Court [BFH], ruling of Oct. 23, 2019, XI R 17/19). So, someone with €30,000 in revenue and a €12,000 margin exceeds the previous year’s threshold.
How much VAT do I pay on my profit margin?
19% of the net margin, which is 15.97% of the gross margin. Under the differential taxation method, the general tax rate always applies (Section 25a(5), first sentence, of the UStG), even for goods that would otherwise be taxed at 7%, such as used books.
If the selling price is lower than the purchase price, there is no margin and therefore no VAT on that item. Under the individual difference method, each item is calculated separately. A loss on one item is not offset by other items or by losses in later periods (Section 25a.1, Paragraph 11 of the VAT Implementation Regulations).
Costs incurred only after the purchase—such as those for repairs—are not included in the purchase price and do not reduce the margin for VAT purposes (Section 25a.1, Paragraph 8 of the VAT Implementation Regulations).
Model Calculation: Sneakers from a Private Collection—Standard Taxation and Differential Taxation Side by Side
- Commercial reseller, not a small business owner, tax year 2026.
- Purchase of a pair of sneakers from a private individual for €120, excluding VAT.
- Sale to a private customer for €220 (gross).
- Fees and shipping are not included in this sample calculation.
- As of October 2026.
| Standard taxation: VAT on €220 (× 19/119) | €35.13 |
| Standard Taxation: Input Tax on Purchases from Private Individuals | €0.00 |
| Standard taxation: applies after VAT and purchases | €64.87 |
| Differential taxation: VAT on a €100 margin (× 19/119) | €15.97 |
| Differential taxation: calculated based on VAT and purchases | €84.03 |
| Difference in VAT for this sale | €19.16 |
Both methods are permitted; the differential taxation method is not mandatory: You may opt out of it for each delivery (Section 25a(8) of the UStG). Under standard taxation, a buyer who is a business owner herself receives an invoice showing the VAT; under differential taxation, there is no tax statement and she is not entitled to a tax credit.
How much VAT do you have to pay on your sale, and how much is left?
Model calculation, as of October 2026, tax years 2025 and 2026. Applies only to business owners who are not small business owners. The total difference, works of art and collectibles pursuant to Section 25a(2) of the UStG, and foreign transactions are not included.
What's the deal with a lot of inexpensive parts? The total difference
For goods with a purchase price of up to €750, you may report the total of all margins for a given period instead of reporting each item individually (Section 25a(4) of the UStG). The law refers to this as the “total difference”: the sum of the sales prices minus the sum of the purchase prices for transactions during a tax period, i.e., the calendar year.
For vintage resellers with boxes full of individual items, this is part of everyday life: buying a box of jackets for €125 and selling them individually throughout the month. The difference from selling items one by one is that an item sold below cost reduces the margin on the other items during the same period.
There are two conditions attached to this. Anyone who uses the total difference can no longer opt out of the difference taxation for individual shipments (Section 25a(8), first sentence, of the UStG). And for items with a purchase price exceeding €750, the individual difference rule still applies.
If the total difference for a given year is negative, the tax base is €0. The negative amount does not carry over to the next year. Within the same year, negative and positive months are offset against each other based on the advance returns (Section 25a.1, Paragraph 13 of the VAT Implementation Regulations).
Sample calculation: three vintage jackets in the same month
- All three jackets were purchased from private sellers, each for less than 750 €.
- Tax Year 2026, monthly estimated tax payment.
- As of October 2026.
| Jacket 1: €95 (sale price) − €40 (purchase price) | + €55 |
| Jacket 2: €70 sale price − €25 purchase price | + €45 |
| Jacket 3: €50 (sale price) − €60 (purchase price) | − €10 |
| Individual difference: Margins only for the items with a positive value (55 € + 45 €), VAT × 19/119 | €15.97 |
| Total difference: 215 € − 125 € = 90 €, VAT × 19/119 | €14.37 |
| VAT Based on the Total Difference | €14.37 |
In terms of the total difference, the negative value for Jacket 3 partially offsets the margin of the other two. In terms of the individual difference, Jacket 3 counts as zero.
What must be included on the invoice under the differential taxation method?
The notation “Used Goods/Special Rule” and no separately stated tax amount. This is governed by Section 14a(6) of the UStG. For works of art, the notice reads “Works of Art/Special Provision”; for collectibles and antiques, it reads “Collectibles and Antiques/Special Provision.”
Practical implication: Your customers see the final price, but neither the tax amount nor the markup. The other required information on an invoice remains the same.
Records Expected by the Tax Office
- Purchase price per item, with proof of purchase (personal receipt showing the date, seller, item, and price for purchases from private individuals)
- Selling price per item
- Tax base, i.e., margin excluding VAT, per unit or as the total difference per period
- Separate records if you also sell goods that are subject to standard taxation (§ 25a(6) UStG)
How do I record the purchase of goods in the EÜR?
The purchase price is considered a business expense in the year you pay it. The income-surplus accounting method (EÜR) compares business income with business expenses (Section 4(3), first sentence, of the Income Tax Act (EStG)), and expenses are recognized in the year they are paid (Section 11(2) of the Income Tax Act (EStG)). Merchandise is not included among the exceptions listed in Section 4(3), sentence 4, of the German Income Tax Act (EStG), which are deducted only upon sale.
For resellers, this means: If you purchase a large collection in December 2025 and sell it in 2026, the purchase reduces your profit in 2025, while the sales increase your profit in 2026. The differential taxation does not change this. It applies only to VAT, not to income tax.
Income tax is levied on business profits. Trade tax only applies if the business income exceeds the €24,500 exemption threshold for sole proprietors (Section 11(1) of the Trade Tax Act).
Income and Expense Statement (EÜR) – Simple profit calculation for self-employed individuals and small business owners who are not required to keep accounting records: operating income minus operating expenses, each recognized in the year the cash flows in or out (Section 4(3) of the Income Tax Act).
VAT and Simplified Accounting in One Place
taxtastic prepares your simplified income statement, your VAT return, and your advance VAT return (free of charge), and submits them to the tax office via the official ERiC interface.
Get Started with taxtasticAt what point does reselling become commercial?
As soon as you engage in sales on a sustained basis—that is, repeatedly and systematically—and act as a merchant in the process. For VAT purposes, sustained activity aimed at generating revenue is sufficient; an intent to make a profit is not required (Section 2(1), sentence 3, of the UStG).
The Federal Fiscal Court looks at the big picture: duration and intensity, number of sales, amount of revenue, and whether the individual acts like a dealer. Anyone who sells at least 140 fur coats belonging to others via an online platform in their own name is considered an entrepreneur (BFH, ruling of Aug. 12, 2015, XI R 43/13). By contrast, anyone who sells items from their own collection generally does not act like a dealer (BFH, ruling of April 26, 2012, V R 2/11). There is no fixed number of items.
If you're selling items from your personal collection, the rules for private sales apply, with a one-year time limit and a €1,000 exemption limit. This is explained in the article on collectibles.
Quick question, quick answer.
As a reseller, do I have to apply the margin tax?
No. If the requirements are met, it applies; however, you can opt out of it for each individual shipment and pay taxes as usual, as long as you don't use the total difference.
Does the differential taxation apply to sneakers I bought from a retailer?
No, if the purchase invoice includes VAT. In that case, the standard taxation rules apply, and you deduct the VAT from the purchase invoice as input tax.
What tax rate applies to used books under the differential taxation system?
19%. Under the differential taxation system, the general tax rate always applies, even to goods that would otherwise be subject to a reduced tax rate.
What happens if I sell an item for less than the cost price?
With the individual difference, no VAT is due for this part; however, the negative amount does not reduce the margin on other parts, not even in later periods. With the total difference, it is offset against the margins of the other parts in the same period.
For the small business threshold, does the margin or revenue count?
Revenue. The Federal Fiscal Court bases its assessment for resellers subject to differential taxation on total revenue, not on the margin (judgment of October 23, 2019, XI R 17/19).
Do I need a receipt for purchases from private individuals?
Yes. The purchase price must be recorded; otherwise, the margin cannot be verified. If there is no invoice, a handwritten receipt with the date, seller, item, and price will suffice.
Sources & Legal Basis
- German VAT Act, Differential Taxation – § 25a UStG (Abs. 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8)
- German VAT Act, Invoice Information in Special Cases – § 14a Abs. 6 UStG
- German VAT Act, Tax Rates – § 12 Abs. 1 UStG
- German VAT Act, Small Business Owners – § 19 Abs. 1 UStG
- German VAT Act, Business Owners – § 2 Abs. 1 Satz 3 UStG
- BFH: Small Business Threshold for Margin Taxation – BFH, Urteil vom 23.10.2019, XI R 17/19 (nach EuGH C-388/18)
- BFH: Scheduled Sale via an Online Platform – BFH, Urteil vom 12.08.2015, XI R 43/13
- BFH: Entrepreneurial Status in Sales via an Internet Platform – BFH, Urteil vom 26.04.2012, V R 2/11
- Income Tax Act, Determination of Profit, and Inflows/Outflows – § 4 Abs. 3 Sätze 1 und 4, § 11 Abs. 2 EStG
- Trade Tax Act, Exemption – § 11 Abs. 1 GewStG
- VAT Application Directive, Differential Taxation, and Total Sales – Abschnitt 25a.1 Abs. 5, 8, 11, 13 UStAE; Abschnitt 19.2 Abs. 2 Satz 5 UStAE
- Trade Tax Act, Exemption – § 11 Abs. 1 Satz 3 Nr. 1 GewStG
This article is intended to provide general information and does not constitute tax advice for specific cases. For binding information, please contact your local tax office.
Reviewed by expertsSven Schilling
Tax expert- Bachelor of Business Administration (University of Applied Sciences)
- Over 30 years of experience in accounting and tax firms
- Board Member of an Income Tax Assistance Association
Reviewed on November 11, 2026. If there are any changes to the law, this post will be reviewed again.
It goes well with it.
Small Business Exemption: Thresholds of €25,000 and €100,000 Starting in 2025
The small business rule applies if total revenue in the previous year did not exceed 25,000 euros and does not exceed 100,000 euros in the c …
Self-Employed & Small BusinessesPreparing an EÜR: The Income-Surplus Account, Step by Step
Under the EÜR method, profit is calculated as the excess of operating income over operating expenses (Section 4(3) of the Income Tax Act (ES …
Differential Taxation for Reselling Got it.
Sign up now.
taxtastic asks only the questions relevant to your situation, calculates based on the figures for your tax year, and submits everything via ELSTER.
Sign up for free and give it a try